The Return Of Barking Cat Syndrome
Well, I suppose it would be fair to say that this is not strictly a ‘return’ of Barking Cat Syndrome since the condition never really went away in the first place. However, it has most definitely re-manifested itself in the form of Libertas.
In 1973, Milton Friedman wrote a column in the American magazine Newsweek entitled, Barking Cats, which attacked the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for its bureaucratic control of pharmaceutical drugs, and acted as a follow-up to previous works that he had co-written with his wife calling for the abolition of the Food and Drug Administration.
In his column, Friedman addressed his critics who had argued that the FDA should not be abolished but that instead its powers should be changed in various different ways. Friedman wrote:
What would you think of someone who said, ‘I would like to have a cat, provided it barked’? Yet your statement that you favor an FDA provided it behaves as you believe desirable is precisely equivalent. The biological laws that specify the characteristics of cats are no more rigid than the political laws that specify the behavior of governmental agencies once they are established. The way the FDA now behaves, and the adverse consequences are not an accident, not a result of some easily corrected human mistake, but a consequence of its constitution in precisely the same way that a meow is related to the constitution of a cat.
In his memoirs fifteen years later, Milton Friedman remarked that the column was one of the best he’d ever authored, both in substance and form. Furthermore, such an argument directly relates to the proposed aims of Declan Ganley’s new trans-European political party, Libertas.
Ever since his involvement in the Irish No Vote to the Lisbon Treaty back in June last year, Mr Ganley has consistently stressed that he is in favour of the European Union – it’s just that he wants it to reform and become more democratic. Ganley said:
It sends a very clear message to those unelected elites and bureaucrats, who seek to daily interfere in our lives more closely, that this cannot go on without proper accountability. The EU needs to change. Libertas believes in a strong Europe but also believes unless democracy is at the heart of that we’ll never be able to deliver.
Yet, like a cat that cannot bark, the European Union cannot be democratic because that is not the way it was designed to be. At its heart the EU’s institutions were deliberately created with the intention of being able to make decisions without public approval.
Thus, the EU is democratically unreformable and as such you are left with only two choices: either remain in it and submit yourself to being undemocratically run by it, or leave and forge your own destiny. There is no in between.
